Zadorin1

NDI Briefing Note: Prospects for the development of the White Sea-Baltic Canal

Northern Dimension Institute Briefing Note | February 2021
 
PROSPECTS FOR THE DEVELOPEMENT OF THE WHITE SEA-BALTIC CANAL
 By Maksim Zadorin, Northern Arctic Federal University, Arkhangelsk
m.zadorin [a] narfu.ru

The White Sea-Baltic Canal, constructed in 1931-1933 as a large-scale Soviet infrastructure project and therefore commonly referred to as the “Stalin’s Canal” [1], often evokes negative connotations due to its history. The Canal itself connects Lake Onega to the White Sea, but it also provides access from the White Sea to the Baltic Sea and to the Volga-Baltic Waterway via Neva and Svir rivers and Lake Ladoga (Fig. 1) [2]. Therefore, the Canal is an integral part of the waterway infrastructure in the Northern Dimension area, and provides one option to connect Baltic Sea ports to the White Sea and further to the Northern Sea Route.

Zadorin1

Fig. 1 The location of the White Sea-Baltic Canal

The White Sea–Baltic Canal route is 227 kilometers long and it runs from the village of Povenets on Lake Onega to the city of Belomorsk on the White Sea. Its infrastructure is considered sophisticated even according to contemporary standards, as the channel with an average depth of 5 meters includes more than 100 complex hydraulic structures including 15 weirs, 19 locks, 49 dams, 12 waterways, and other devices. Today, the canal is the largest hydro-technical and transport facility and part of the unified deep-water system of the European part of Russia. The infrastructure of the White Sea-Baltic Canal was improved between 1976 and 1983, including the reconstruction of 13 lock chambers on a rocky foundation, rebuilding of 27 out of 38 bays (hydraulic retaining wall or flyover), and replacing 7 pairs of riveted sluice gates with all-welded gates [3].

The traffic on the White Sea-Baltic Canal has increased significantly in recent years, both as to freight traffic and passenger traffic (Fig. 2) [5]:

 Zadorin4

Fig. 2 Growth in the volume of freight and tourist traffic along the White Sea-Baltic Canal 2018-2019

Recently, the development of the White Sea-Baltic Canal has been taken on the agenda of the authorities of the Republic of Karelia, the Russian region on the territory of which the Canal runs. This is due to the tourism potential of cultural heritage in Northwest Russia, including the tourist route to the Solovetsky Islands that passes through the Canal, and to the increased freight traffic on the Northern Sea Route that the Canal is linked to.

As to measures addressed to the development of the White Sea-Baltic Canal as a tourist route, the Government of the Republic of Karelia approved in the end of July 2020 a document called “Procedure for the implementation of measures of the individual program of socio-economic development of the Republic for the period from 2020 to 2024” (hereinafter – the Economic Program of Karelia) [4]. This program includes two measures that address the development of the White Sea-Baltic Canal, particularly as a tourist route.

  • Elaboration of the concept for the development of the White Sea-Baltic Canal (2020, responsible governmental body: Ministry of Transport of the Republic)
  • Working out the issue of creating and promoting an international water cruise route along the coast of the Scandinavian Peninsula (Norway) to the city of Arkhangelsk and further through the White Sea-Baltic Canal to St. Petersburg (2020, responsible governmental body: Ministry of Tourism of the Republic).

Furthermore, the text of the Economic Program of Karelia includes the development of tourist routes in the following directions, jointly with the Finnish side:

  • “Kuusamo-Suoperä border checkpoint – White Sea”;
  • “North Karelia (Finland) – Vyartsilya – Ladoga area”;
  • “Saimaa Geopark – Syväoro checkpoint – the projected national park “Ladoga Skerries”.

The infrastructure for these routes (roads and railways, inland water transport) is planned to be prepared through the modernization of the Canal and the development of the archaeological complex “White Sea Petroglyphs” (application to UNESCO) (Fig. 3) [7] [8].

Zadorin3 

Fig. 3. Zalavruga. The architectural concept of the development of the archaelogical complex “White Sea Petroglyphs”. © Evgeni Taev’s architectural studio. 

There are, however, some regulatory and infrastructural constraints to the development of international tourism operations on the Canal. Tourist companies operating on the Canal mainly use river passenger ships, which, according to the latest rules of the Russian River Register (RRR) are prohibited from entering the sea. Therefore, tourists are moved to a ferryboat, which raises the question about the use of large cruise ships of foreign companies that exceed the dimensions of the canal [6].

As to the prospects of developing freight traffic on the Canal, the Government of Republic of Karelia proposed in 2019 to make the White Sea-Baltic Canal as part of the Northern Sea route, which would give boost for the development of its infrastructure. Until now, there have been no concrete steps to implement this idea, but the need to improve the transportation and logistics infrastructure on the Northern Sea Route in general has been recognized in the Federal policies of the Russian government. For example, the development of the Northern Sea Route is included as one of the projects in the document “Comprehensive plan for the modernization and expansion of the trunk infrastructure for the period up to 2024” [9] that the Russian Government approved in the fall 2018. More generally, the Plan intends to develop both East-West and North-South transport corridors for the transportation of goods.

The development need is obvious in view of the rising economic activity in the Arctic and resulting traffic on the Northern Sea Route, which has reflected in the increase in the volume of cargo turnover in Arctic ports. For example, in 2016, the total cargo turnover of all Arctic ports was 49.7 million tons, and by 2018 it had already reached 92.7 million tons of which the cargo turnover of the White Sea port of Murmansk amounted to 60.7 million tons [10].

In this context, the development of the White-Sea Baltic Canal as part of the transportation infrastructure related to the Northern Sea Route would be justified. This would, however, require a comprehensive assessment of the short-term and long-term economic potential of the White Sea-Baltic Canal. This assessment should address issues such as the capacity of the Canal port to receive large-tonnage vessels , which have been identified as bottlenecks for the development of transportation activities on the Canal.

Sources:
[1] Belomorsko-Baltiyskiy kanal imeni Stalina. Istoriya stroitel’stva 1931–1934 gg. / pod red. M. Gor’kogo, L. Averbakha, S. Firina [White Sea-Baltic Canal named after Stalin. Construction history 1931–1934 / ed. by M. Gorky, L. Averbakh, S. Firin]. Moscow, 1934.
[2] White Sea-Baltic Canal Map. Wikimedia.org.
[3] The history of the construction of the White Sea-Baltic Canal [Istoriya stroitel’stva Belomorsko-Baltiyskogo kanala]. August 02, 2013, 09:30 (updated: 12:17 01.03.2020). RIA Novosti. URL: https://ria.ru/20130802/953345579.html
[4]Governmental Resolution of the Republic of Karelia of July 29, 2020 No. 371-R “On Approval of the Procedure for the Implementation of Measures of the Individual Program of Socio-Economic Development of Karelia for 2020–2024”. URL: http://docs.cntd.ru/document/465425041
[5] Plan modernizatsii Belomorkanala vklyuchat v programmu razvitiya Karelii do 2024 goda [Modernization plan of the White Sea-Baltic Canal into the development program of Karelia until 2024], October 20, 2020, 16:29. TASS. URL: https://tass.ru/ekonomika/9767725
[6] Belomorsko-Baltiyskiy kanal – perspektivy v gabaritakh [White Sea-Baltic Canal – perspectives in size], July 11, 2014, 00:06. Korabel.ru. URL: https://www.korabel.ru/news/comments/belomorsko-baltiyskiy_kanal_-_perspektivy_v_gabaritah.html
[7] Turistam iz Norvegii predlozhat marshrut po Belomorkanalu. Novye turisticheskie planiruyut zapustit’ do 2024 goda [Tourists from Norway will be offered a route along the Belomorkanal. The new tourist is scheduled to launch by 2024], June 2, 2020, 14:37. Respublika. URL: http://rk.karelia.ru/ekonomika/turistam-iz-norvegii-predlozhat-marshrut-po-belomorkanalu/
[8] Stoyanka u petroglifov. Proekt turisticheskogo kompleksa ryadom s belomorskimi petroglifami: neytral’naya arkhitektura dlya budushchego ob’ekta iz spiska UNESCO [Parking at the petroglyphs. The project of a tourist complex near the White Sea petroglyphs: neutral architecture for a future object from the UNESCO list], October 01, 2020. Archi.ru. URL: https://archi.ru/russia/87514/stoyanka-u-petroglifov
[9] Comprehensive renovation plan and background infrastructure expansion for the period until 2024. Government of the Russian Federation. URL: http://static.government.ru/media/files/mMrrbr3q9P6cGfWP3WxSmf7lCvAhrLob.pdf
[10] Serova N.A., Serova V.A. Critical tendencies of the transport infrastructure development in the Russian Arctic. Arktika i Sever [Arctic and North], 2019, no. 36, pp. 42–56. DOI: 10.17238/issn2221-2698.2019.36.42
 
 
lippurivi